Books like Shutter Island

12 picks with a similar feel

Shutter Island is, above all, a dark, intricate psychological thriller. It keeps returning to deeply flawed leads and mysteries that aren't what they seem.

These 12 books have a similar feel, ranked by how closely they match. They are picks to try, not a definitive list.

Based on Shutter Island (2003) by Dennis Lehane.

  1. 1

    by Alex Michaelides4.1

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as dark and intricate, with deeply flawed leads.

  2. 2

    by Wilkie Collins4.1

    Why it's like Shutter Island: A classic mystery with the same interest in mental health.

  3. 3

    by Lucy Foley4.8

    Why it's like Shutter Island: A mystery that also deals with island life.

  4. 4

    The Magus (1965)

    by John Fowles3.8

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Another inventive psychological thriller about island life.

  5. 5

    by Paula Hawkins3.6

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as intricate and dark, with deeply flawed leads.

  6. 6

    by Freida McFadden3.9

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as dark and intimate, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  7. 7

    by S. J. Watson4.0

    Why it's like Shutter Island: The same inventive and intimate feel, built around mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  8. 8

    by Riley Sager3.9

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as intricate and dark, with deeply flawed leads.

  9. 9

    by A. J. Finn3.8

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as intimate and dark, with deeply flawed leads.

  10. 10

    by Mary Higgins Clark4.7

    Why it's like Shutter Island: The same dark and weighty feel, built around deeply flawed leads.

  11. 11

    by Alice Feeney3.6

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as intricate and dark, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  12. 12

    by Michael Chabon3.9

    Why it's like Shutter Island: Just as intricate and dark, with deeply flawed leads.

Boxlist compares Shutter Island with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers. There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point. Ratings are Open Library reader averages out of 5.

Which of these suit you?

Take the taste test and every pick shows how well it matches you.

Take the taste test

Questions

What should I read if I like Shutter Island?
Books with a similar feel include The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides, The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins, The Guest List by Lucy Foley and The Magus by John Fowles. Each one shares something real with Shutter Island, whether that is its tone, its themes or what it is about; the full list has 12 books.
How are these books like Shutter Island chosen?
Boxlist compares Shutter Island with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers. There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point.