Books like Sherlock Holmes
12 picks with a similar feel
Think of A Study in Scarlet, the first Sherlock Holmes book, as an intricate, inventive classic mystery about detectives. The big themes are injustice and revenge, and mysteries that aren't what they seem.
Below are 12 books with a similar feel, the closest matches first. Think of them as suggestions, not a definitive list.
Based on A Study in Scarlet (1887) by Arthur Conan Doyle.
- 1
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (1926)
by Agatha Christie4.2
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: Also an inventive classic mystery about detectives.
- 2
The Case of the Velvet Claws (1933)
by Erle Stanley Gardner4.0
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: Another intricate classic mystery about detectives.
- 3
by Gilbert Keith Chesterton4.3
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: Just as inventive and intricate, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.
- 4
The Haunted Bookshop (1919)
by Christopher Morley4.1
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A classic comic mystery with the same interest in detectives.
- 5
The Moonstone (1868)
by Wilkie Collins4.1
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: Just as inventive and intricate, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.
- 6
Killing Floor (1997)
by Lee Child3.8Faster-paced
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A thriller built on mysteries that aren't what they seem.
- 7
The Nine Tailors (1934)
by Dorothy L. Sayers3.8Heavier option
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: Also an intricate classic mystery about detectives.
- 8
by Douglas Adams4.0Lighter option
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A comic novel that also deals with detectives.
- 9
Bloodline (1977)
by Sidney Sheldon4.7
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A thriller that also deals with detectives.
- 10
The Red House Mystery (1922)
by A. A. Milne4.5Slower burn
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A classic comic mystery that also deals with detectives.
- 11
"A" is for Alibi (1982)
by Sue Grafton3.7Darker
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: A mystery that also deals with detectives.
- 12
The Guest List (2020)
by Lucy Foley4.8Darker
Why it's like Sherlock Holmes: The same intricate feel, built around injustice and revenge.
Boxlist compares Sherlock Holmes with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers. There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point. Ratings are Open Library reader averages out of 5.
Which of these suit you?
Take the taste test and every pick shows how well it matches you.
Take the taste testQuestions
- What should I read if I like Sherlock Holmes?
- Books with a similar feel include The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha Christie, The Case of the Velvet Claws by Erle Stanley Gardner, The Innocence of Father Brown by Gilbert Keith Chesterton and The Haunted Bookshop by Christopher Morley. Each one shares something real with Sherlock Holmes, whether that is its tone, its themes or what it is about; the full list has 12 books.
- How are these books like Sherlock Holmes chosen?
- Boxlist compares Sherlock Holmes with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers. There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point.
- Is there a lighter book like Sherlock Holmes?
- Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency by Douglas Adams has a similar feel but scores lighter on Boxlist's weightiness scale.
- Why are there no other Sherlock Holmes books here?
- The list is for what to read after Sherlock Holmes, so the rest of the series is left out, and so are sequels to any other story: each pick is a place to start.











