Books like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

12 picks with a similar feel

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder is an intricate, intimate young adult mystery. Expect growing up, injustice and revenge, and mysteries that aren't what they seem.

Below are 12 books with a similar feel, the closest matches first. Think of them as suggestions, not a definitive list.

Based on A Good Girl's Guide to Murder (2019) by Holly Jackson.

  1. 1

    by Karen M. McManus4.1

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intimate, with growing up.

  2. 2

    by Philip Pullman3.8

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intricate, with injustice and revenge.

  3. 3

    by Christopher Pike4.0

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as weighty, with injustice and revenge.

  4. 4

    Allegedly (2017)

    by Tiffany D. Jackson4.6

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: The same intimate and weighty feel, built around injustice and revenge.

  5. 5

    by Jennifer Lynn Barnes4.2

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intimate, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  6. 6

    by Kerri Maniscalco3.9

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intimate, with mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  7. 7

    Promise Me (2006)

    by Harlan Coben4.3

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Has the same intimate feel.

  8. 8

    by John Green3.9Easier to follow

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intimate, with growing up.

  9. 9

    by Angie Thomas4.6Easier to follow

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: The same intimate and weighty feel, built around growing up.

  10. 10

    Flawless (2006)

    by Sara Shepard3.7

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: The same intimate feel, built around growing up.

  11. 11

    by Leslie McFarlane4.5Lighter option

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: The same intimate feel, built around mysteries that aren't what they seem.

  12. 12

    by Jay Asher3.7

    Why it's like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Just as intimate and weighty, with injustice and revenge.

Boxlist compares A Good Girl's Guide to Murder with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers (young adult books). There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point. Ratings are Open Library reader averages out of 5.

Which of these suit you?

Take the taste test and every pick shows how well it matches you.

Take the taste test

Questions

What should I read if I like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder?
Books with a similar feel include One Of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus, The Ruby in the Smoke by Philip Pullman, Fall Into Darkness by Christopher Pike and Allegedly by Tiffany D. Jackson. Each one shares something real with A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, whether that is its tone, its themes or what it is about; the full list has 12 books.
How are these books like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder chosen?
Boxlist compares A Good Girl's Guide to Murder with every fiction book in its catalogue on 15 taste scores (pace, tone, weight, realism and more), story themes, genres and Open Library subjects, and ranks the closest. Every pick has an Open Library rating of 3.6 or more from at least 5 readers, and is aimed at the same readers (young adult books). There is one book per author, and sequels that carry on an earlier story are left out. It is an approximation of feel, so treat it as a starting point.
Is there a lighter book like A Good Girl's Guide to Murder?
The Moonstone Castle Mystery by Leslie McFarlane has a similar feel but scores lighter on Boxlist's weightiness scale.