I Think Not!
True crime · Ongoing · ~38 min
Taste attributes: comedycrimedocumentarytalk-showunsavouryrealisticlinearenclosedemotive & stirringsolving the riddle/not as it seemstroubled leads
Boxlist takeA realistic true-crime podcast that is contained and dark. Best if you like close-up stories over spectacle.
Taste details
Pace: balanced · Originality: balanced · Tone: dark · Weight: balanced · Realism: true to life · Story: balanced · Structure: linear · Look: balanced · Scale: confined · Emotional punch: balancedHow we score
Based on your film and TV taste: podcasts are matched on the same ten characteristics, with your own match bands.
About this podcast
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Elly…
Description: from the show's own feed
Characteristics
Where this podcast sits on each taste spectrum
Genres and themes
Where to listen
Details
- Publisher
- I Think Not!
- Format
- Ongoing
- Typical episode
- About 38 minutes
- Latest episode
- 9 November 2026
- Categories
- True Crime, Society & Culture, Comedy
- Taste scores
- How we score
How podcast matches work
Podcasts are scored on the same ten characteristics as films and matched with your own match bands, from your film and TV taste. The scores are estimates, from fixed rules plus a one-off AI reading of each show's own description and episode titles. Quality badges never change your match.
Similar in feel
Matched on pace, tone, themes and production, not just genre.
Podcast data from Podcast Index and the shows' own feeds. Charts from Apple Podcasts.