Sherlock vs Elementary

Sherlock is grittier, more intricate and more true to life; Elementary is more familiar. Both are fast-paced, heavy and intricate.

Sherlock poster

Sherlock

Type and year
TV series · 2010
Length
4 seasons · 12 episodes · 90 min episodes
Rating
8.5
out of 10 on TMDB · 3,205 votes
Elementary poster

Elementary

Type and year
TV series · 2012
Length
7 seasons · 154 episodes · 43 min episodes
Rating
7.5
out of 10 on TMDB · 1,181 votes

Which fits you better?

Take the two-minute taste test to see how well Sherlock and Elementary each match your taste, and which one to watch first.

Take the taste test

Characteristics, side by side

SherlockElementary

  • Pace
    SlowFast
  • Originality
    Tried & testedFresh & original
  • Wholesomeness
    UnsavouryWholesome
  • Weightiness
    LightHeavy
  • Realism
    ImaginaryRealistic
  • Intricacy
    SimpleIntricate
  • Linearity
    SurrealLinear
  • Style and visuals
    GrittyGlossy
  • Scale
    EnclosedBig & varied
  • Emotional punch
    Emotionally undemandingEmotive & stirring

Taste attributes

Both

  • Crime
  • Drama
  • Mystery
  • Mafia/gangster
  • Detective
  • Fast
  • Heavy
  • Intricate
  • Linear
  • All consuming quest
  • Complex relationship
  • Deep rivalry
  • Fighting evil
  • Solving the riddle/not as it seems

Only Sherlock

  • Realistic
  • Gritty

Only Elementary

  • Adventure
  • Action
  • Unsavoury
  • Empowerment/personal growth
  • Troubled leads

Genres

Both

  • Crime
  • Drama
  • Mystery

Only Sherlock

None.

Only Elementary

None.

Where to watch

More comparisons

All comparisons